Отзывы Whiskybase
учтено 13 заметок · текстовых 10 · полный lossless-снимок WB (полнота подтверждена)
Суммаризация отзывов
Отзывы описывают дымный, солёно-мясной Caol Ila с хорошо интегрированным высоким градусом, который часто раскрывается с добавлением воды. Мнения сходятся на сочетании морских, копчёных и слегка сладковатых нот при хорошем соотношении цены и качества.
развернуть подробно
В отзывах виски последовательно описывают как дымный и морской: упоминаются торфяной дым, соль, морской бриз, копчёный бекон и мясные ноты, иногда с оттенками цитруса, жёлтых фруктов, тёмных ягод и шоколадной сладости. Отмечается, что высокая крепость хорошо интегрирована и не подавляет остальные ноты, а добавление небольшого количества воды делает напиток мягче и элегантнее, раскрывая его на новом уровне. Финиш чаще описывают как длинный, дымный, солёный и постепенно высыхающий, с пряными и травянистыми оттенками.
Общий тон отзывов позитивный: виски называют хорошо сбалансированным, характерным и приятным, при этом несколько раз подчёркивается хорошее соотношение цены и качества и отсутствие юношеских, металлических или резко алкогольных нот. Часть отзывов отмечает, что напиток не отличается высокой сложностью, но остаётся цельным и выразительным, с типичными для Caol Ila нотами. Один отзыв описывает аромат как деликатный, винный и кисловатый, а вкус — как более мягкий и плоский с дымом и тёмными фруктами на фоне.
собрано 10/13 текстовых отзывов · полный lossless-снимок WB
· 2026-10-08T07:05:52Z · источник evidence
нос 88 · вкус 86 · финиш 84
Very impressed by this malt, not over sherried and the smoke is impressive. A little water and it opens up to another level.
I like it a little better with water.
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос | 86 | A touch of smoke, alcoholic spice, ham, citrus notes |
| Вкус | 87 | Strong start, sweetish, ham, smoke, pepper |
| Финиш | 87 | Long, smoky, salty |
A enjoyable and very drinkable Caol Ila. I call this one a ‘islay-lite’ and is well balanced with the smoky, meaty and salty character. The high ABV is not overbearing but enhances the whisky.
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос | 88 | Peat Smoke, brine, smoked bacon, vegetation and hints of menthol - nose not too overbearing. |
| Вкус | 88 | Continued peat smoke, meaty , brine, background sweetness (chocolate) |
| Финиш | 87 | Dry, smoky, pepper. Aftertaste of coastal funkiness and salt. |
A fine example from the SV 100 Proof series. Not very complex, but well-rounded and flavorful. Adding a little water makes it more elegant without diluting it. Good value for money.
нос · вкус · финиш
| Нос | 86 | Neat, it's slightly smoky, with a subtle note of smoked ham, followed by grain, oil, a hint of citrus, and musty hay. Nicely rounded. With water, it becomes a bit smoother. Perhaps somewhere in the distance, there's a hint of a chocolate wrapper washed up on the beach. |
| Вкус | 86 | A full, rounded start with smoke, malt, slightly astringent, and hints of Burgundy ham. The alcohol is very well integrated, leaving a light tingle on the tongue like a pinch of white pepper; it can easily be drunk neat. Matured appropriately for its age. Typical Caol Ila notes are present but subtle. |
| Финиш | 84 | Rather long finish, smoke, herbal candy, slightly maritime mineral note. |
Of course, you can also buy Caol Ila as an official Diageo bottling. It costs just over €40 and comes at 43% ABV, featuring chill filtration and coloring. How wonderfully thoughtful of Diageo! For just under €5 more, you can get it uncolored and without flavor-robbing filtration, at a robust 57.1% ABV. This comes from Oloroso sherry butts and refill hogsheads in the Signatory 100 Proof Edition. It's really a no-brainer which Caol Ila is preferable. glen-efze.de
нос 85 · вкус 86 · финиш 86
As always, Caol Ila from the 100 proof series confirms and is a guarantee of quality. Brine and smoked meat with added sea salt with the sherry sweets. Well balanced with long finish.
нос 88 · вкус 89 · финиш 89
This 2012 Caol Ila is from Signatory Vintage's 100 Proof Edition #70 and was bottled at a robust 57.1% ABV after 13 years. It was matured in first-fill and refill Oloroso sherry butts as well as a refill hogshead. In the glass, it initially displays a pleasantly maritime and smoky character. Salty sea breeze and peat smoke mingle with lemon, yellow fruits, and apricots, while roasted nuts add a more bitter note. On the palate, it becomes sweeter: dark berries combine with peat smoke, oak, and citrus notes. A slightly earthy, rustic character adds to the whisky's appeal. The finish is medium-long and becomes increasingly dry, leaving behind spicy oak, peat smoke, and herbal notes. All in all, this is a characterful, smoky Caol Ila that combines maritime and fruity elements with a spicy, dry edge. It doesn't come across as overly complex, but offers a coherent overall impression and is enjoyable precisely because of its slightly gritty, tart character. The 57.1% ABV gives it considerable substance without overshadowing the smoky and fruity notes.
нос 85 · вкус 86 · финиш 84
Incredible what this whisky can do. A maritime, salty bacon note, with smoke. Can be enjoyed neat very well; the alcohol is superbly integrated. So, for a low price, a top-notch whisky without any flaws.
aroma: delicate, wine-like, sour taste: mild, flatter, smoke, dark fruit in the background I wouldn't guess smoke from the smell, the taste is better, but hmm I don't know
For the price, it's a real find; it's well-made and shows neither youthful, immature, metallic or alcoholic harsh notes, and is therefore also good to enjoy undiluted.
Hvdree
mijyksihw
Sporx
Ogoshigus
Gold_Savourer
glen efze
Shaggy
Alex_Whisky_Corner
whiskypag
xraycer
duranadavid
11insomnium
