учтено 40 заметок · текстовых 20 · полнота WB не подтверждена (legacy wb_reviews: один автор — одна запись)
Суммаризация отзывов
Молодой ирландский виски (3 года) с травянисто-цветочным профилем и заметной шоколадно-солодовой сладостью; большинство находит его удивительно характерным для возраста, но опытные критики упрекают в незрелости, спиртуозности и слишком высокой цене.
развернуть подробно
В аромате преобладают свежескошенный луг, травы и цветы, дрожжевое тесто и марципан (маркеры молодости), жёлтые фрукты, цитрус, груша, а также какао и молочный шоколад; спирт у одних интегрирован хорошо, у других выпирает резкостью. Во вкусе раздваиваются акценты: часть находит насыщенное шоколадно-ирисочно-карамельное ядро с кофе и корицей, другие — солодово-перечное, пряное начало с фруктовостью (груша, банан, вишня), мёдом и сухим белым вином; послевкусие от средне-короткого до долгого, с горчинкой, дубовой сухостью и жгучестью в горле. Хвалят за неожиданную сложность и питкость при малом возрасте, критикуют за зерновисто-опилочную грубость, спиртуозность и незрелый, стянутый хвост.
Оценки согласованы плотно — почти все в диапазоне 81–88. Опытные ревьюеры расходятся сильнее прочих: рядом стоят и восторженные 86–87 («сложность уже есть»), и трезвые 82–83 с вердиктом «разлит слишком рано, поймали бы как образец из бочки — дали бы дозреть», вплоть до резко заниженной 69; рядовые же оценки ровнее и чаще подчёркивают приятную ирландскую сладость, тогда как скептики обеих групп сходятся на том, что terroir и «фермерское» происхождение ячменя — маркетинговый ход, а цена для трёхлетнего виски завышена.
собрано 20/40 текстовых отзывов · полнота WB не подтверждена (собрано локально)
· 2026-07-21 23:30:42 · источник wb_whiskies (историческое поле, без evidence)
DefeatlessConnoisseur8502 oct 2020 12:33 am
This is quite a good whiskey, although young it doesn't feel much like it. Yet I would like to see this one back in 6 years. I think it might be sublime.
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
86
Sweet, grassy, wet forrest. Quite herbal so to say. A bit yeasty and you get some marzipan notes which indeed indicate young age. Although this is quite well integrated already, this has potential to grow to big standards!
Вкус
85
Sweet and flowery. Herbal notes are here again. Some coffee and chocolate notes (with a swirl of Tia Maria). Not aggressive at all.
Финиш
84
Medium length. Here there is a little nib of the young age, a tad bitter and a tad unrested. Overall quite some caramel layered finish.
Hupsende HippieExpert Senior8603 jun 2021 4:55 pm
SeattleHuskyConnoisseur8203 jun 2025 5:36 pm
From the flavor, you can taste some traces of the traditional whiskey craftsmanship of the last century, but the woody and grassy notes of the new wood are too heavy, and the overall balance is still not good. 84 83 82 Update: How come the wine smells bad after being sober for about 10 minutes?
нос 83 · вкус 82 · финиш 81
FicelliConnoisseur8603 mar 2021 7:16 pm
нос 86 · вкус 87 · финиш 86
Erik1908Expert Senior8203 oct 2020 4:48 pm
Waterford, the new mystery distillery from Ireland. If I got things right, Waterford will be able to produce a wide variety of different tastes, by using barley from different local farmers, each with their own style and flavors. The first bottles have now been released and I was lucky enough to get a sample of the first 4 different bottles. This is the 2nd one I get to taste.
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
85
Nose is for sure the best. part Young, grassy and sweet. It again reminds me of a young grain whisk(e)y.
Вкус
81
It again goes wrong in the taste. Oily and thick. Slightly alcoholic and bitter.
Финиш
80
Things do not get better in the finish. Bitter and unpleasant spices. Two down, two to go, but I am not really convinced about Waterford (yet).
kanpai79Specialist8505 dec 2020 8:10 pm
нос 84 · вкус 85 · финиш 85
FoudosConnoisseur8106 may 2023 9:34 am
нос 81 · вкус 81 · финиш 80
stefan_PBExpert Senior8506 oct 2020 11:13 am
A very appealing malt for its age.
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
88
At first there is a note of malt that is already moving towards beer. These flavors are superimposed relatively quickly by a fruit pot pourri. One discreetly recognizes banana, a little more present peach and also some orange peel. Perhaps there is also a hint of sea buckthorn here. A light herbal aroma and beeswax scent round off the odor profile. Very rich and great on the nose.
Вкус
84
The first sip reminds of hot milk for a moment. Then there is sweetness and fruitiness. Another subtle banana. But now some cherry and dried fruit. If you taste it for a long time, tones of vegetables and a light white wine note come through. The longer you have it in your mouth, the more pepperiness and spiciness it develops. It is a very strong and full whiskey.
Финиш
84
Long with sharpness that lasts for a long time. At the end the sharpness subsides and the initial sweetness comes out again.
Taste: Vanilla, honey, buttery, tart wood, bitter caramel, bitter citrus, wet hay, peppery and alcoholic. 83.00
Финиш
82
Finish: Medium-short, buttery, cocoa powder, tart, bitter, citrus peel, dark chocolate, unpleasant burn in the throat. 82.00
Lu CiferConnoisseur8107 jun 2021 12:16 pm
нос 81 · вкус 82 · финиш 80
Tangtang_WhiskyYodaConnoisseur8407 nov 2020 4:45 pm
very tasty Irish, surprised me positively, especially for the young age. Quite tasty.
Erik1702Expert Senior8108 aug 2024 10:29 pm
Nose: Sweet, grain, sawdust, vanilla, some light fruit, light grape, some pear, glucose? ••• Taste: Sweet, grain and some sawdust, vanilla, some spices, oak ••• Finish: Medium long, sweet grain and light spices with vanilla remain. After a while some pear peel ••• Conclusion: The nose offers primarily notes of grain and sawdust with a certain sweetness. Vanilla and some light fruit are very faintly behind it. After a while light grape comes to the fore, along with some pear and perhaps a hint of cherry. The strong grain note subsides somewhat over time. I still have a note that reminds me of glucose. The 50% is present at the beginning of the taste. Sweet notes and some grain and sawdust are there again. Then vanilla and some light fruit come. Oak is also there. Overall a difficult whiskey. Difficult to decipher and the alcohol is only halfway well integrated. If you don't like a very present grain note you should avoid the whiskey.
LittlePeatExpert Senior8409 nov 2020 7:26 pm
нос 85 · вкус 83 · финиш 84
thijs100Connoisseur8711 feb 2021 3:42 pm
Lots to like and explore here. It's undeniably young whiskey but the complexity is already there.
dapoinbuaConnoisseur8111 mar 2021 8:46 pm
нос 83 · вкус 79 · финиш 82
SquinugieConnoisseur8412 feb 2022 1:23 pm
нос 84 · вкус 86 · финиш 83
Dramming DutchmanConnoisseur8512 nov 2022 10:43 pm
нос 85 · вкус 85 · финиш 84
RienConnoisseur8512 sep 2020 2:01 pm
нос 86 · вкус 84 · финиш 84
IgitorConnoisseur7514 may 2021 7:58 pm
нос 82 · вкус 72 · финиш 74
WtrstrnghltExpert Senior8417 mar 2021 8:18 pm
нос 85 · вкус 84 · финиш 83
STLExpert Senior8517 mar 2021 8:48 pm
нос 85 · вкус 86 · финиш 85
rolabobConnoisseur8317 oct 2020 6:55 pm
нос 83 · вкус 84 · финиш 83
davidloosliExpert Senior8318 feb 2021 8:00 am
young but interesting
craideConnoisseur8318 nov 2020 7:37 pm
Delicious Irishman. Waterford's range is fun. Not bad here either, what can be put into it at such a young age. Only the price is too high.
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
84
Grassy, floral notes with herbs, light citrus with some pear and gooseberries. Somewhat malty, fresh sourdough, a bit earthy with little wood influence. Everything smells rather fresh.
Вкус
83
Malty, peppery, spicy start. Subtle note of sweetened chamomile tea, Goes in the direction of honey sweetness. Fruity like banana, pear. Fruitiness is more subtle, dry white wine, somehow also a bit chocolaty, alcohol is well integrated.
Финиш
82
Medium-long finish, malt, marzipan, slightly bitter and dry
RobbievdBExpert Senior8318 oct 2020 4:01 pm
During the taste I get that typical Irish Whiskey sweetness, but overall I find this first edition of Waterford Sheestown not that impressive. Sure you’ve got to praise them for releasing this at young age and it’s interesting to see how this will be when it approaches 10yo. Back to the whiskey; grassy, quite some wood shavings and wood spices, some young unripe fruits and dashes of chocolate. Quite herbal and earthy.
besarConnoisseur8319 feb 2021 10:46 am
нос 83 · вкус 83 · финиш 82
ArcherConnoisseur8619 sep 2020 10:27 pm
Fascinating whiskey. 3 years, 10 months, 25 days old. If you leave aside the somewhat tight finish, you won't notice his very young age. Thanks to the incredible fermentation time of 131.5 hours? Cannot be determined that way. But the fact is that it is quite a board now - and I catch myself filling the empty glass with one last, but now really last, sip.
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
86
A freshly mown meadow that was not only covered with grass, but also provided with wild herbs and flowers. Fresh and floral with a hint of fresh yeast dough. Marzipan, milk chocolate.
Вкус
87
Rich and very chocolaty start. Toffee, fudge, milk chocolate, milk coffee dusted with cinnamon. Dry wood, dried apricots, whereby the fruit notes have only a very subtle appearance. The focus is clearly on chocolate and fudge, cocoa also mixes in over time, so that you get the impression of having a liquid chocolate-fudge-caramel candy in your mouth.
Финиш
86
The chocolate notes slowly fade, here and there a bit of spiciness of pepper appears, which is then softened again by cinnamon and coriander. Cold coffee with milk, coffee grounds, an indefinable sweetness.
SRBConnoisseur8820 sep 2020 10:37 pm
Drinks amazingly well, more of it.
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
87
Chopped herbs, pizza dough, fresh leaves, green bananas, blooming moor, slightly mineral and flowery The alcohol is very well integrated.
Вкус
87
Fudge candy, sweet, white pepper, green grapes, a drop of honey, matches Difficult to describe, not particularly complex, yet full of body and no missing notes.
Финиш
86
Briefly spicy, then a malty-fruity sweetness remains
claymore84Expert Senior8321 dec 2020 1:06 am
Tasted on 12-20-2020.
sjoerd972Expert Senior8422 apr 2025 10:49 am
Sniff: Lots of barley, but after a little while, the typical Waterford sweetness starts coming through. Pound cake, a hint of white port, or sweet white dessert wine. A hint of soil too. Sip: A rather gentle whiskey, with a combination of sweetness and a dry note of barley. Sweet with the same combination of pastry and dessert wine. Slightly more green with grass and ferns. Swallow: The finish is similar, but not the same. Dry and green with some sweetness. Less barley, more hay and grass.
Paddy_GlenConnoisseur6922 sep 2025 10:03 am
50+3+6+8+2
martinsecoExpert Senior8223 may 2025 2:45 pm
Even if the barley used comes from a single farm, this stuff is far too expensive for a 3-year-old whiskey (or even whiskey, for marketing purposes, and the double distillation...), even if it's bottled at 50%. In my opinion, the taste differences between bottlings with farm names are due to the variety of different cask types. I consider attributing the differences to the terroir or the barley of a specific farm to be purely a marketing gimmick.
нос 82 · вкус 83 · финиш 81
DenverbroncosDukeConnoisseur8523 sep 2020 9:00 pm
Surprisingly good Irish whiskey with a lot of character for the young age
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
86
Sour cherries, nice sweetness, lots of dried fruits
Вкус
86
Wonderful elegant Irish sweetness, again sour cherries, coconut
Финиш
82
Slightly smoky, very elegant, nice sweetness
WiltChamberlainConnoisseur8825 jul 2022 9:57 pm
нос 87 · вкус 89 · финиш 88
HlektrionConnoisseur8326 dec 2021 12:34 pm
нос 83 · вкус 83 · финиш 82
SporxConnoisseur8226 mar 2023 11:48 pm
Aroma Fruity, citrus notes, alcohol sharpness The taste Creamy, overripe fruit, alcohol sharpness, citrus notes aftertaste Medium length, hot, sweet, slightly astringent, chili
junyvyaoConnoisseur8428 mar 2025 5:56 am
нос 85 · вкус 85 · финиш 83
Dre73Connoisseur8329 sep 2021 3:54 pm
Not too bad, but for me an example of a whiskey bottled way to early. Too much on the alcohol, it has quite some scent and taste, but not that deep yet. If it would have been a cask sample, I would say: it's doing well, good on it's way, but give it some more years and we try again. Unfortunately, it's too late for this one.
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
82
Fruity, pretty some alcohol noticeable, citrus, fresh, some glue as well.
Вкус
83
Strong, pickering, pepper, fruity again, light (white) fruits, pear, citrus as well, a touch of sweet and then even some lingers of musty notes.
Финиш
83
Still pretty strong, sweet and fruity, some bitterness now, but pretty long.
GLENRIGIConnoisseur8131 mar 2023 6:59 pm
нос 81 · вкус 82 · финиш 81
Оценки по участникам WB
эксперты 83.5среднее только по явному allowlist ролей; служебные роли не считаются экспертизой
снимок #11858 ·
статус complete · собран 2026-09-13T17:32:48+00:00 ·
сверено: строки сходятся с объявленным числом
· ожидалось 171,
фактических строк 171, сохранено 171
экспертный allowlist: Expert Junior, Expert Senior, Specialist, Connoisseur.
Служебные роли (Administrator, Community Manager, Editor, Photo Moderator, Shoplink Moderator, Super Administrator) остаются ролью, но
экспертизой не объявляются. Авторское смещение не применяется:
author-bias correction not applied; view is raw observations.
показано 44 из 144 (экспертных наблюдений;
всего в снимке 171)
· страница 3 из 3 · за страницей ещё 100
Одно наблюдение = одна строка исходной таблицы;
повторные оценки одного автора сохраняются. «Дата неизвестна»
означает отсутствие даты в источнике, а не время сбора.
Defeatless
Connoisseur
85
02 oct 2020 12:33 am
Hupsende Hippie
SeattleHusky
Ficelli
Erik1908
kanpai79
Foudos
stefan_PB
ezioaudit
Damek
Lu Cifer
Tangtang_WhiskyYoda
Erik1702
thijs100
dapoinbua
Squinugie
Dramming Dutchman
Rien
Igitor
Wtrstrnghlt
STL
rolabob
davidloosli
craide
RobbievdB
Archer
SRB
claymore84
sjoerd972
Paddy_Glen
martinseco
DenverbroncosDuke
WiltChamberlain
Hlektrion
Sporx
junyvyao
Dre73
GLENRIGI
